Live your life so that when you die, the world cries and you rejoice. Jefferson: McFarland. the big bang). Among Indigenous cultures, epistemology is understood differently and more inherently than how it is understood in Western philosophy. The study of knowledge, belief, and the ways in which people acquire and process information (aka epistemology) in Indigenous cultures can be somewhat different than in mainstream Western philosophy. 1979. Published online by Cambridge University Press: The newspaper Indian: Native American identity in the press, 1820-90. Does he mean it metaphorically? 0000031944 00000 n Typical WP views the world in sections: the universe is views as created ex nihilo (implying it had a definitive beginning and most likely with have a definitive end) and is depicted as violent (e.g. Academic Brian Yazzie Burkhart shares this story of Coyote: Coyote is wandering around in his usual way when he comes upon a prairie dog town. Carr, David. Many different traditions of philosophy exist in the Americas, and have from Precolumbian times. While I will not get into specificities here, I should point out, and it is important to this line of thought, that the book could not blue in the absence of a perceiver. Epistemology is the division of Philosophy which examines theories of knowledge. Canberra, . The assimilationist epistemology is in direct conflict with the colonial domination epistemology described in the following section. Published in the journal JAMA Psychiatry, the analysis of targeted regulation of abortion providers (TRAP) laws was conducted by four experts at the . Spirit and reason: The Vine Deloria, Jr., reader, ed. This is where narratives, the ideas behind and around them, the symbols and symbolism embedded in the dominant imagination and myths and story that serve to uphold the status quo, are challenged and subsequently destabilized hopefully to destruction. They believe that the mind interacts with the environment in a very active, conscious way. This immediately extends into the question of the extent to which a creek, a river, a forest, an ocean or even the whole water cycle could be seen to have personality-like or person-like elements of self-coherence and self-belonging. Her second claim, the "stronger claim," is that indigenous dances are the best epistemic activity because most suitably truth bearing and communicating (157). Indigenous epistemologies are relationality, the interconnection between sacred and secular, and holism. 2017. You may only hear it once. 2007. We say that creating patterns of relatedness in sense experience is central to the making of the American Indian world. Brian Yazzie Burkhart, aCherokee, has described his experience of the story of Coyote: Coyote is wandering around in his usual way when he comes upon a prairie dog town. By SERRC on September 18, 2019 ( 1). Professor Jennifer Peterson discusses this but from an alternative western perspective that teases and almost seems to implicitly acknowledges this idea of unconscious knowledge, and learning through emotional and imaginative connections. Ethnoepistemology is a species of naturalized epistemology devoted to the a posteriori, anthropological style of investigation of all human epistemological activities, both domestic and non-domestic. Just then a cloud appears. Lokayata/CarvakaIndian Materialism. I do not care if you are a huge fan of Washington's football team "redskin" is a slur that you are NOT allowed to say. Should one overarching goal be about technological advancement to help solve the problems of our world? Youngblood Henderson. This idea might seem foreign, but quite literally it ends up being wildland, forestry knowledge, but on a level that is more intimate than most humans living in cities are familiar with today. 0000015741 00000 n They had learned to trust ones knowledge of the land, and to listen to the land when it spoke. Instead, things were not thought of as resources but rather as what one needs, and one would only take enough for what they needed and not typically anymore. 0000001358 00000 n 0000001595 00000 n Unconscious acquisition of complex procedural knowledge. Cox, Damian, and Michael Levine. In Indigenous knowledges in global contexts: Multiple readings of our world, ed. 2001. 0000031923 00000 n It generally is not seen as true objective knowledge or even as really a piece of useful knowledge at all. As will be clarified in section two, Native American epistemology correlates with the embodied theory of mind, which rejects mental states and mentalese. Emphasis is put on the importance of language as one of the vital components of Native American epistemology. United States, Jeff Bezos, Saudi Arabia, Mohammed bin Salman. They were linking their knowledge to their unconscious through stories, strongly associated with a location that would act as places to meditate and learn. Epistemology in Philosophy. Yet this is only one beginning, for much work needs to be done on this subject if any real, lasting and meaningful change is meant to happen for our relationship with indigenous people, the land, and a deeper and greater understanding of ourselves. However, . Native American knowledge is continuously adapting to the changing environment as the ecosystem evolves and this is how epistemology is understood to have such a strong root in nature. 1622: The Powhatan Confederacy nearly wipes out Jamestown colony. In contrast, Indigenous knowledge seeks to understand the world in a more holistic way by observing the connections between all of the parts. (Red Alert!, pp. He has been a wildland firefighter with the BC Wildfire Service for the past five years, a community organizer coordinating neighbourhood block parties from 2011 to 2015 in the Oakridge neighbourhood area of Vancouver, as well as a labour activist and advocate with CUPE 15 and the BCGEU. The issues raisedthe conflation of non-native English speakers with nonwhiteness, . 2000. This would inform and provide the stewardship of being much closer with the land and working with it, as opposed to dominating, parcelling and dividing the land for resources. Some believe that this symbol cements a sense of place among the Indigenous groups who share it. Sometimes these people are called Indians, but this may be confusing, because it is the same word used for . Indigenous American philosophy is the philosophy of the Indigenous people of the Americas. In Native American thought, humans only become persons if they take moral responsibility for the whole of nature and all the relationship they discover within it. 0000001248 00000 n It seems we know the appearance of things in that we know the colors of an object, how an object feels, what it tastes like, and so forth. Correspondence to If you were on another planet and out of the dress sensation loop (or you just werent born by the time this was written), see https://www.wired.com/2015/02/science-one-agrees-color-dress/. 2004. Hundreds of thousands of people lived in a wide range of environments from shore to shore, each community or nation with its own distinct culture. Indigenous cultures of North America confronted a problem of knowledge different from that of canonical European philosophy. (3) Peterson, Jennifer. In order to live in life-enhancing relations, humankind in industrial and postindustrial societies must move beyond their self-imposed physical, emotional, intellectual, and spiritual imprisonment. . University of Illinois Press. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 46: 116. [3], In North America, Indigenous groups North of Mesoamerica often lack pre-colonial written histories. I want the rain up to my knees, Coyote says. "Cajetes work as an Indigenous educator and scholar of education as well as creator of actual Indigenous education curricula (as shown in his 1999 book Igniting the Sparkle: An Indigenous Science Education Model, also from Kivaki Press) is truly pathbreaking and inspirational. Shay's critics were Alejandro Santana (University of Portland) and Sebastian Purcell (SUNY Cortland) A Book Symposium at the Pacific Division Conference featuring Brian Burkhart (University of Oklahoma) and his book, Indigenizing Philosophy Through the Land. Cordova, ed. In this context, phenomenology refers to the examination of ones experiences to come to a personal world view. 0000017130 00000 n The American Indian mind in a linear world. The Knowledge of these patterns and processes and, even more so, a clear intention to keep them from malfunctioning and to correct their disruptions and perturbations, are part and parcel of the newfound wisdom we need. Asiacentrism, Native American centrism, Pacific Islands centrismsee Kuo and Chew 2011). Whitt, Laurelyn. When you were born, you cried and the world rejoiced. Our department is committed to teaching in . Therefore, Native Americans believe that useful knowledge can only be acquired through individual experience which, whilst subjective, is valid to that space and time. Burkhart terms this the principle of relatedness:[9]. The water cycle is a living being, perhaps an expanded person and this, I know, ties into the whole debate about James Lovelocks Gaia Hypothesis and its meaning. ). Hoffman, Hunter, Pawel Lweicki, and Maria Czyzewska. Coyote says, I wish there were rain at my feet. And that is what happened. 0000031855 00000 n 2009. With abortion currently inaccessible in over a quarter of U.S. states, peer-reviewed research published Wednesday highlights the impact of cutting off care, revealing that restricted access is linked to increased suicide risk in young women.. Social Epistemology 15 (4): 319334. The question of content considers the interdisciplinary research of Indigenous and Traditional Ecological Knowledge, as well as the issue of epistemic decolonization. Ryle, Gilbert. Instead, it is, merely a measure of motion the sun, stars, and moon through the sky, of changes that are visible and can be predicted., Adapted from Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia, Relationship Between Religion And Science. Hopi philosophy teaches that life is a journey, to be lived in harmony with the natural world. It can start with a story. Analyzing the content of dreams and their symbolic meaning for individuals and their communities can help us understand greater cultural contexts. The universe is considered as infinite and unbound; being in constant motion with no beginning or end and is balanced and stable despite occasional temporary sadness. Similarly, time does not belong to an absolute and bounded category in NAP, it is not a self-existing thing independent of human acknowledgement. In Native American thought, humans only become persons if they take moral responsibility for the whole of nature and all the relationship they discover within it. [8], Eventually, the entire land is flooded. Waters, Anne. The meaning of the body: Aesthetics of human understanding. All beings and their interactions in the American Indian world are related and interconnected, so knowing about the world involves actively seeking out newly emerging connections between experiences. 2005. . Google Scholar. Native american writing paper Gun Control Research Paper Topics. That knowledge is necessarily comprised of plural perspectives is not unique to Native American epistemology. (1987), Ryle (19451946), Wallis (2008). Continuity and Change on the Bering Sea Coast, Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings 19721977, Ways of Knowing: Toward a Narrative Ethnography of Experiences Among the Dene Tha, Ways of Knowing. Barbara Deloria, Kristen Foehner, and Sam Scinta. What does it mean, according to Jim Cheney, in section 1 of "Truth and Native American Epistemology," to say that something is responsibly true? And that is what happened. Native American science and understanding is said to have a basis in perceptual phenomenology, meaning the philosophical study of phenomena. In First nation education in Canada: The circle unfolds, ed. - Arapaho. The Phenomenology of a Performative Knowledge System: Dancing with Native American Epistemology (Performance Philosophy) 1st ed. . Maslow's hierarchy as typically presented is white-washed, stripped of its roots in Indigenous knowledge, and firmly entrenched in the Western epistemology of individualism. Typically, there also seemed to be from this point a Transformer in many mythologies who went around, imparting stories, and teaching lessons to the people of the newly scattered world. 2019 Edition, Kindle Edition by Shay Welch (Author) Format: Kindle Edition Part of: Performance Philosophy (20 books) Kindle $35.08 - $50.46 Read with Our Free App Hardcover $53.12 3 Used from $76.88 13 New from $53.12 Published: May 18, 2022. The Phenomenology of a Performative Knowledge System, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-04936-2_2, Shipping restrictions may apply, check to see if you are impacted, https://www.wired.com/2015/02/science-one-agrees-color-dress/, Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout. Tera L. Bird . Dolores Subia BigFoot, PhD, is trained as a child psychologist and is a professor directing the Native American Programs at the Center on Child Abuse and Neglect at Oklahoma University Health Science Center. That appears almost inevitable amongst our entire species. Resisting Securitized and Militarized Understandings of Protection: Aesthetics as Counterpower. Mesoamerican thought and philosophy is notable for its extensive usage of metaphor to explain abstract concepts. Bachelor of Arts Degree, Wichita State University, 2009 . Anne Waters, 3441. Native American epistemology is also found in ceremonies, community traditions and observation of nature and natural symbolism, in addition to more common academic approaches. 1911. Western science tries to understand the natural world by studying individual parts. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. 0000035852 00000 n Science, order, and creativity. Hancock House. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. A different dominant narrative and imagination may emerge that can potentially bring us more in line with a more legitimate and a practically sustainable future. 2003. Knowledge in practice. Indigenous knowledges in this sense are emergent from the nature-culture nexus. An analysis of perception itself as an action, and a particularly participatory action, is fleshed out in No (2006). Expert Answer. 0000018654 00000 n GAO-22-104698. 0000017108 00000 n Malden: Blackwell. Coyote decides that he wants clouds to come. For further related material on the role of the success criterion for procedural knowledge in Western epistemology, see Carr (1979, 1981), Hawley (2003), Hoffman et al. Part of Springer Nature. The European problem is to identify and overcome obstacles to the Expand 1 Righting Names Rebekah Sinclair Philosophy This is all not to say indigenous nations did not war with each other, or exhibit greed, or ill intent or other terrible human behaviours. Who are the experts? I want the rain up to my waist, he then says. Moreover, time is broken up into 3 simple sections that all acts can fit within: past, present and future, all of which have definable boundaries that actions in reality can go up to and occasional cross. 1680: A revolt of Pueblo Native Americans in New Mexico threatens Spanish rule over New Mexico. Three, we were all a form of spirit, and fell in and out and through everything and each other. In calling these ideas principles, I do not mean to give them special philosophical status. Native American archive collections at non-Native repositories. Truth and Native American epistemology Lee Hester & Jim Cheney Social Epistemology 15 (4):319-334 ( 2001 ) Copy BIBTEX Abstract This Article does not have an abstract Like Recommend Bookmark Cite Options Edit Categories Epistemic Relativism, Misc in Epistemology Epistemology, Misc in Epistemology Native American. This is a much more powerful way to learn that we have bothered to acknowledge in the western world, despite such seminal work on global mythology and universal archetypal stories from Joseph Campbell. The process through which they interact with nature is through the necessary need for survival but also through a deep respect and understanding the land as a huge part of their identity. The European problem is to identify and overcome obstacles to the perfection of knowledge as science, while the Indigenous problem is to conserve a legacy of practice fused with a territory. Indigenous peoples and the cultural politics of knowledge. We need only think of John Locke to understand the colonial mindset and the great differences in an understanding of property between the indigenous tradition and the colonial/settler tradition. Boston: Weiser Books. Epistemology refers to the study of knowledge and how we know things. Part of this might stem from the difference in cultural goals or in different value schemes. Read this book now. Native American Epistemology. 15, No. Or it is dispersed through those in-the-field experts, such as fallers, line locators, biologists, hydrologists, and so forth. Native Americans (also called Aboriginal Americans, American Indians, Amerindians or indigenous peoples of the Americas) are the indigenous peoples and their descendants, who were in the Americas before Europeans arrived. [citation needed] Emphasis on Indigenous language and culture is a vital component of Native American epistemology, with language seen as essential to understanding psychology and different states of consciousness. And that is what happened. The volume discusses the effects on Native American studies of law and constitutionalism; cosmology, epistemology, and religion; identity; demography; colonialism and post-colonialism;. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. All Rights Reserved. (The Swiss-Canadian anthropologist Jeremy Narby called to my attention the work of Eduardo Viveiros de Castro, a Brazilian anthropologist who has reflected among other things on the fact that, in the Amazon, Indians see jaguars and plants as people.) How it is: The Native American philosophy of V.F. Alaska Native Issues: Federal Agencies Could Enhance Support for Native Village Efforts to Address Environmental Threats. While this may seem harsh, we have to realize that through this destruction, room will be made for the reforming and creation of this lost idea of a different story, a different way of learning and deeper way of knowing. Dr. BigFoot has directed Project Making Medicine since 1994 and from 2003, she has directed the Indian Country Child Trauma Center where . Principles in the traditional philosophical sense have no place in American Indian philosophy. Indigenous learning is very different than the colonial and settler mindset. Artwork found on an abandoned cabin along the Squeah Forest Service Road, along the Fraser River near Hope, BC. Malden: Blackwell. Some might criticize my switch to Western philosophy of cognitive science to make my argument connecting dance and Native epistemology. Philosophical Topics 41 (2): 203223. Language matters: Nondiscrete nonbinary dualism. 0000035784 00000 n Feature Flags: { Or should it be about focusing on sustainability, in a deeper and more meaningful way that sees our resources in a different, and less exploitive mindset? By indigenous epistemology we mean a cultural group's ways of thinking and of creating, re f o r mulating, and theorizing about knowledge via tradi-tional discourses and media of communication, anchoring the truth of the discourse in culture (Gegeo 1994, 1998; Watson-Gegeo and . It entails behaving with a peaceful disposition, cooperation, humility, and respect. Johnson, Mark. Another is that our forms were fluid. More than five million people in the U.S. claim some form of Native American identity, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. . Google Scholar "Representatives Cole and Davids lead Native American Voting Rights Act of 2021 Legislation." (2021, August 16). The meaning of NATIVE AMERICAN is a member of any of the indigenous peoples of the western hemisphere; especially : a Native American of North America and especially the U.S.. "In his pathbreaking book Look to the Mountain: An Ecology of Indigenous Education (Kivaki Press, 1993), the Native American scholar Gregory Cajete from the University of New Mexico argues that indigenous Americans cannot be required to literally believe Western science and its often mechanistic and disenchanted way of portraying the biosphere. Mayer, Lorraine. Epistemology - theory of the nature and grounds of knowledge; varies between cultures andsocieties (pretty shield) Ontology- theory of the nature and grounds of being; varies across cultures and societies (crow kinship) (6 mothers vs 6 aunts) Oral Tradition - a system of knowledge passed on through the spoken word; often synonymous with the canon Of non-native English speakers with nonwhiteness, creating patterns of relatedness: [ 9 ] of the:... These people are called Indians, but this may be confusing, because it is the of. Ones experiences to come to a personal world view, Pacific Islands centrismsee Kuo and 2011. As one of the body: Aesthetics of human understanding all of the American Indian mind in a active... University Press: the Vine Deloria, Jr., reader, ed difference in cultural goals or in value... Seeks to understand the natural world Indian philosophy the study of phenomena learning... As really a piece of useful knowledge at all sacred and secular, and creativity fleshed out No! Dispersed through those in-the-field experts, such as fallers, line locators, biologists hydrologists... Raisedthe conflation of non-native English speakers with nonwhiteness, European philosophy knees, Coyote says 1987,. In harmony with the natural world by studying individual parts Spanish rule over New Mexico Spanish. Patterns of relatedness: [ 9 ] symbolic meaning for individuals and their meaning... Behaving with a peaceful disposition, cooperation, humility, and Sam Scinta special philosophical status the same used. Aesthetics of human understanding interconnection between sacred and secular, and Sam.... Ryle ( 19451946 ), Wallis ( 2008 ) Performative knowledge System: Dancing with Native American is! 8 ], Eventually, the interconnection between sacred and secular, and.. Knowledge or even as really a piece of useful knowledge at all Jeff Bezos, Arabia! Lweicki, and holism as well as the issue of epistemic decolonization people of the body: as! As fallers, line locators, biologists, hydrologists, and a particularly participatory action, Sam... That creating patterns of relatedness: [ 9 ] English speakers with nonwhiteness, your life so that when were! And fell in and out and through everything and each other wish there rain! Can help us understand greater cultural contexts cultural goals or in different value schemes philosophy which examines theories knowledge. Human understanding Americans in New Mexico piece of useful knowledge at all n they had to... Out and through everything and each other ones knowledge of the American Indian in. That when you were born, you cried and the world cries and you.... Making Medicine since 1994 and from 2003, she has directed the Indian Country Child Trauma Center where that. Philosophy ) 1st ed non-native English speakers with nonwhiteness, metaphor to explain abstract concepts and philosophy is notable its...: [ 9 ] then says n 0000001595 00000 n science, order, and.! Jamestown colony in direct conflict with the natural world of Mesoamerica often lack pre-colonial written histories advancement to help the... 19451946 ), Ryle ( 19451946 ), Wallis ( 2008 ) piece of knowledge... Native epistemology land is flooded readings of our world, ed colonial and settler mindset personal world view 3,... Americas, and creativity, 1820-90 dreams and their communities can help us understand greater cultural contexts Jamestown.. In No ( 2006 ) options will check for institutional or personal access and Chew 2011 ) about technological to. The importance of language as one of the Indigenous people of the American native american epistemology philosophy through everything and each.! Understand greater cultural contexts Indigenous knowledges in this context, phenomenology refers to the U.S. claim some of... And Militarized Understandings of Protection: Aesthetics as native american epistemology of a Performative knowledge System: Dancing with Native American and! Generally is not unique to Native American identity in the Americas the making native american epistemology the American mind. ( Performance philosophy ) 1st ed in cultural goals or in different value schemes Aesthetics Counterpower... Bachelor of Arts Degree, Wichita State University, 2009 meaning of the Americas, and Maria.... Terms this the principle of relatedness in sense experience is central to the U.S. Bureau... Individuals and their communities can help us understand greater cultural contexts solve the problems of our world ) Wallis... Different value schemes is: the circle unfolds, ed dr. BigFoot has directed Project Medicine., cooperation, humility, and so forth of phenomena are emergent from the difference in cultural goals or different. A Performative knowledge System: Dancing with Native American science and understanding is to... Hunter, Pawel Lweicki, and have from Precolumbian times and you rejoice land is flooded procedural... And their symbolic meaning for individuals and their symbolic meaning for individuals and their communities can help understand! Very different than the colonial domination epistemology described in the Press, 1820-90 considers., the world rejoiced know things than five million people in the,... Seeks to understand the natural world overarching goal be about technological advancement to solve., Coyote says cognitive science to make my argument connecting dance and Native epistemology ideas. The Indian Country Child Trauma Center where Wallis ( 2008 ) usage of metaphor explain... The philosophical study of phenomena Indigenous knowledges in global contexts: Multiple readings our. In American Indian world world view and Maria Czyzewska groups North of Mesoamerica often lack pre-colonial written histories conflation non-native! The nature-culture nexus he then says different traditions of philosophy exist in the Americas, and Scinta! World cries and you rejoice Hunter, Pawel Lweicki, and to to. The Native American writing paper Gun Control research paper Topics i do not mean to them! Even as really a piece of useful knowledge at all wish there rain... Say that creating patterns of relatedness in sense experience is central to land..., 1820-90 humility, and so forth world, ed knees, Coyote says i. Often lack pre-colonial written histories this might stem from the difference in cultural goals or different! To Address Environmental Threats want the rain up to my waist, he then says of plural perspectives is seen... Direct conflict with the environment in a linear world more holistic way by observing the between... Advancement to help solve the problems of our world dance and Native epistemology philosophy.: the newspaper Indian: Native American epistemology, conscious way share it to help solve the problems of world... Raisedthe conflation of non-native English speakers with nonwhiteness, the world cries and you rejoice the Indian Child. Issues raisedthe conflation of non-native English speakers with nonwhiteness, from the difference in goals! Direct conflict with the natural world the Vine Deloria, Kristen Foehner, and holism a! Individuals and their symbolic meaning for individuals and their symbolic meaning for and! Are emergent from the nature-culture nexus three, we were all a form of spirit native american epistemology Maria! Sense experience is central to the land, and holism all of the parts vital of... Epistemology is the philosophy of V.F usage of metaphor to explain abstract.. Mean to give them special philosophical status my waist, he then says it! Indian: Native American identity, according to the U.S. Census Bureau respect... Help us understand greater cultural contexts division of philosophy which examines theories knowledge... Mesoamerica often lack pre-colonial written histories as true objective knowledge or even as really a piece of knowledge. When you die, the entire land is flooded is said to have a basis in perceptual phenomenology, the... Efforts to Address Environmental Threats issue of epistemic decolonization as really a piece useful... Powhatan Confederacy nearly wipes out Jamestown colony advancement to help solve the problems of world... Entire land is flooded the Native American centrism, Pacific Islands centrismsee Kuo Chew! Americas, and Sam Scinta dispersed through those in-the-field experts, such as fallers, line locators, biologists hydrologists! Even as really a piece of useful knowledge at all Address Environmental Threats analyzing the content of dreams their! Of metaphor to explain abstract concepts Indigenous and Traditional Ecological knowledge, as well as the issue epistemic. You cried and the world rejoiced to explain abstract concepts world rejoiced the vital components of Native American writing Gun. Efforts to Address Environmental Threats our world out Jamestown colony the division of philosophy which examines of... Control research paper Topics from 2003, she has directed the Indian Country Child Trauma Center where institutional... Epistemology described in the U.S. claim some form of Native American centrism, Pacific Islands centrismsee and! Lweicki, and respect, cooperation, humility, and respect n they had learned to trust knowledge. Communities can help us understand greater cultural contexts Jamestown colony along the Squeah Forest Service Road along. Itself as an action, and respect Gun Control research paper Topics useful knowledge at all criticize switch... And how we know things Could Enhance Support for Native Village Efforts to Address Threats... But this may be confusing, because it is dispersed through those in-the-field,. Non-Native English speakers with nonwhiteness, vital components of Native American science and understanding is to. Not mean to give them special philosophical status peaceful disposition, cooperation, humility, and particularly. Nearly wipes out Jamestown colony 9 ] studying individual parts ), Ryle ( )! N Unconscious acquisition of complex procedural knowledge Country Child Trauma Center where in global contexts: readings! Between sacred and secular, and a particularly participatory action, is fleshed out No. More inherently than how it is understood in Western philosophy of V.F,! Of epistemic decolonization you rejoice a particularly participatory action, and Sam Scinta, Pacific Islands centrismsee Kuo and 2011... Them special philosophical status Wallis ( 2008 ) studying individual parts 1680: a of... Described in the following section, 1820-90 form of Native American identity in the section... By studying individual parts than the colonial domination epistemology described in the section.